Criteo’s Privacy Sandbox Bombshell: Revenue Shortfalls and Industry Shake-ups

AdMonsters Wrapper: The weekly ad tech news wrap up
This Week
July 01, 2024
Criteo's Privacy Sandbox Bombshell
Apple's Ad Attribution Kit
Pubs Invest in Privacy
Criteo’s Privacy Sandbox Bombshell: Revenue Shortfalls and Industry Shake-ups
Did you feel a quake when Criteo dropped that bombshell last week? Their Privacy Sandbox market testing reveals some glaring shortfalls that could leave publishers scrambling. Imagine waking up to find that, if third-party cookies were nixed today, you'd be waving goodbye to a whopping 60% of your ad revenue. Yep, it's that serious.

Todd Parsons, Chief Product Officer at Criteo, spilled the tea on these findings, and it's a wake-up call. The Privacy Sandbox, in its current state, is like a leaky lifeboat. It promises privacy but ends up sinking publishers' revenues. We've seen similar hiccups before. Remember when we covered how publishers were grappling with Google's FLoC trials? Well, this feels like déjà vu but with even higher stakes.

James Rosewell, co-founder of the Movement for an Open Web (MOW), has been sounding the alarm on these issues long before Criteo's report dropped. In our recent LinkedIn Live session, Rosewell dissected the CMA's ongoing scrutiny of Google's Privacy Sandbox. He highlighted the same pitfalls Criteo found — like the potential for reduced publisher revenues and increased market consolidation in favor of Google. Rosewell maintains the need for urgency so Google can address these shortcomings, not just for competitive balance but for the entire digital advertising ecosystem's health.

Criteo's testing wasn't just a casual dip in the pool either. Over eight weeks, they dove deep, running tests across 18,000 advertisers and 1,200 publishers, clocking over 100 million weekly ad impressions. And the results? A boost in Google Ad Manager's market share, skyrocketing from 23% to a whopping 83%, and a nasty 100% increase in ad rendering latency. It's like watching a slow-motion train wreck — painful and avoidable. The current iteration of the Privacy Sandbox, while a step towards more private advertising, still needs substantial adjustments to meet its intended goals. As Rosewell emphasized, the stakes are high, and the industry needs to brace for a bumpy ride ahead.

We've seen these issues before. Last year, we highlighted how publishers were struggling with the rollout of Privacy Sandbox APIs, and it's clear those struggles continue. Criteo's call for Google to expand data limitations, improve machine learning performance, and ensure a more transparent, staged rollout isn't just a wishlist—it's a survival guide. The clock's ticking, and without these changes, digital advertising risks becoming a barren wasteland. Our chat with Rosewell provides additional context and reinforces the critical need for industry-wide dialogue and cooperation to navigate these choppy waters.

Check out the full story here: Criteo Privacy Sandbox Testing Results. And don't miss our detailed chat with James Rosewell for more on the regulatory landscape: LinkedIn Live Rewind.
As always, we'll keep you posted on this saga's latest twists and turns. Stay tuned, because the road to a cookieless future is getting bumpier by the minute. – LdJ
Ad Attribution Kit: The next Evolution in Apple’s Mobile Ad Attribution
Apple's AdAttributionKit (AAK) aims to change the game for mobile app publishers. Introduced at Apple's Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC 2024), this privacy-focused framework builds on the foundations of SKAdNetwork (SKAN) but adds significant upgrades. AdAttributionKit supports the App Store and alternative app marketplaces, offering re-engagement campaigns and improved creative support for ads. In short, it's like SKAN's cool, more versatile cousin.

For publishers, this means more flexibility and better tools for tracking and optimizing ad campaigns across various platforms. You can run AAK alongside SKAN, making the transition smoother for those familiar with Apple's initial attribution framework. AdAttributionKit's developer mode simplifies testing by removing time randomization and shortening conversion windows, which is a big win for fine-tuning your campaigns.

Eric Seufert from MobileDevMemo perfectly captures the sentiment: "AAK unifies Apple's various advertising attribution frameworks under a single umbrella product name and extends SKAdNetwork in meaningful ways, including with support for re-engagement and alternative app marketplaces."

While there's no rush to ditch SKAN just yet, it's clear that AdAttributionKit is the future of Apple's privacy-preserving attribution framework. Publishers should start getting acquainted with AAK to stay ahead of the curve. For more insights, check out our previous coverage of SKAdNetwork and get ready to embrace these new changes. – LdJ
Privacy: The Real Power Play Publishers Shouldn’t Ignore
In Matthew Rance's (Head of Commercial Data & Analytics @ Immediate Media Co) recent LinkedIn post, he takes us down memory lane to the frantic GDPR days of 2018 and argues that privacy, often seen as a "necessary evil," is an untapped goldmine for innovation. Rance's insights hit home for publishers who've been treating privacy as a checkbox exercise rather than a strategic asset. Rance calls for publishers to rethink their approach, align privacy with customer experience, and recognize it as a competitive differentiator. He suggests that privacy should be a fundamental part of our strategy, much like product roadmaps, to build a future-proof digital ecosystem.

This echoes themes we've explored at AdMonsters, particularly in our piece on Europe's bold regulatory moves against Big Tech. The Digital Markets Act and Digital Services Act reshape privacy, emphasizing transparency and fair competition. Rance's points on privacy align perfectly with this regulatory push, highlighting that proactive privacy measures aren't just about compliance but about gaining a strategic edge. Publishers must see privacy as an opportunity to innovate, differentiate, and build trust with consumers and advertisers. It's time we pivot from reactive compliance to proactive leadership in privacy.

Privacy isn't just about avoiding fines or playing catch-up with regulations. It's about redefining how we interact with our audiences and leveraging that trust to build stronger, more sustainable business models. Let's take a page from Rance's playbook and invest in privacy as our next big strategic move. – LdJ
One X Post
X Steps Up Contextual Ad Game
Credit where credit is due: the contextual ad targeting on X/Twitter is now very good.

Not snark. Who knows how much money they make from these ads, but they are indeed relevant.
Worth a Listen
Driving Growth In Today’s Streaming Market
On this episode of The Marketing Insider | A Claritas Podcast, the EVP of Global Media and Entertainment at Magid, Mike Bloxham, and the SVP of Practice Leadership at Claritas, Ron Cohen, share successful acquisition and retention strategies for streaming platforms and their agencies of service. And, since this episode is all about streaming – they turned on the cameras!
Upcoming AdMonsters Events

Facebook   Twitter   LinkedIn